During this season of shopping, I
thought I would address something that has been on my mind for a
while—Walmart. Walmart is popular to dislike these days for various
reasons. A common complaint is that they come into areas and put
small businesses out of business. Also there are cries that they
don't treat their workers fairly. I think that some of the Walmart
bashing comes from the fact that there may be some truth to the
common complaints, but I think most of it comes from the fact that
the bigger something is, the easier it is to attack.
I don't know about the every Walmart
situation, but I can speak about Walmart in the small town that I
grew up in and where my parents still live. First let me describe the
area. The town is in a rural setting and has a population of a couple
of thousand. It is surrounded by farmland and smaller towns. The next
town of any size is about an hour and a half away. The unemployment
rate is in the double digits.
When Walmart built a store there twelve years ago, it was a godsend. First there were new chances for
employment in a place that desperately needed it. And these just
weren't jobs, these were good jobs that actually had the possibility of benefits. Next there were new opportunities for shopping that the
townspeople didn't have before. Shopping, that previously they had
to travel far to do, was now convenient. This was especially important
as the price of gas rose. It was also important for people like my
parents who don't drive long distances any more.
And did all of the local businesses go
out of business when Walmart moved in? No. The local businesses
adapted and provided services that Walmart didn't offer. One of the
drug stores now has a delivery service. One of the grocery stores is
known for having the best meat in town. And sometimes, people just
don't want to deal with the size of the Walmart store, and shop in
the smaller local stores. But all of these people are very happy to
have Walmart available at other times. They appreciate the low prices
Walmart can offer because, as you can imagine in this depressed area,
there's not much money to go around.
And what's the Walmart shopping
experience like in this grateful small town? Wonderful. You can
really tell that people like their jobs and are there to help. The
staff is friendly, helpful, and pleasant. When I shop there, I
sometimes feel as if I'm stepping into a Walmart that I see in
commercials. The customers are also friendly and seem happy to be
there. And no, I'm not exaggerating.
If Walmart is so wonderful here, why is
it not considered wonderful everywhere? My opinion is that in some
places it is an extra option and some places it is not. When you live
in a place where you have multiple choices of where to shop, or when
you have enough income that you can chose to buy something that costs
more because it fits better with your life philosophies, you don't
need Walmart. But when you don't have those options of convenience
and/or a good income, Walmart is truly a godsend.
All your points are well taken, but I still won't shop at our Walmart. I don't want to buy things made in China first. I don't want to buy things that were made by people in horrible working conditions simply because they have no other choice so work for the manufacturers who pay them very little. Then there is the food side of Walmart. I don't care for the taste of the produce which is shipped from all over the country. When needing fresh produce I will first choose my homegrown, then farmers markets, then the local store that tries to buy closer to home.
ReplyDeleteOh and Walmart did close down several local stores here.
I'm not advocating that anyone shop at Walmart. I just wanted to give another perspective to a situation that others may not have thought about. I now live in metropolitan area, and I know many people have specific ideas about where they want to shop and where they don't. For example, I will shop in my neighborhood to support local businesses rather than regularly drive to places like Walmart and Target where I can get better prices. But not everyone has that option. I want people to understand that they are fortunate to have enough income and choices to be able to shop exclusively where they want. I'm not referring to you, but I think there is a lot of Walmart snobbery out there. I think most of the Walmart complaints can be applied to many of the major retailers and not exclusively them.
DeleteIts been mentioned many times before, including by you, but wouldn't it be nice if we could have only American made products for affordable prices? I know that I would be happy with that. But the world of economics is a very complex one, or that is what I understand (or don't understand) when I listen to my son and husband discuss many of these issues. (They both study economics.)
On a more personal level, I would be happy if I didn't have to go shopping at all. It's not my favorite activity.
I was thinking a lot about it too. I understand it's hard for all mamas and papas and their little businesses but to me Walmart is godsend too because I can provide food on the table for our family on a budget. We have a local store that sells exactly the same products mostly but for twice the price, and lots of people will only shop there because they can't stand Walmart. Well, I can't afford it, that's why I do what I can do for my loved ones. On the other hand, my neighbor works for Walmart, and she tells me that all those stories about workers not treated properly are greatly exaggerated. She's been with Walmart for 13 years, starting from the very bottom. Honestly, her health benefits are better than ours, and my husband works for a hospital! I try to shop locally (and grow my own even) but without Wallmart it would be hard for us to make ends meet. That's just my 2 cents :)
ReplyDeleteI have never worked at Walmart or have any family members that do, so I can't speak personally about working there. However, as I said, the people that I know in my little town are very happy to have their jobs. One of the reasons that Walmart gets bad press about how they treat their workers are the unions. The unions have been trying to unionize Walmart workers for a long time and the workers always vote them down.
DeleteEveryone has to do what's right for them and it sounds like that Walmart provides a good service for you and your family. Happy shopping.